| Nick Destefano | 74.35% |
| Mark “The Lumberjack” Filipelli | 69.41% |
| Mark “The Butcher” Carvey | 67.92% |
| Matt "Sure Shot" Riggott | 67.90% |
| Ed "Superfly" Giardina | 67.09% |
| Davey “The Player” Plaisted | 66.17% |
| Mike “Big Shady” Capone | 64.44% |
| Matt “Thunderlips” Boschert | 64.24% |
| Jim “McMahon” Swain | 63.86% |
| George “The Animal” Magyar | 62.16% |
| Chris “Hollow” Point | 61.48% |
| "Stone Cold" Greg Brailsford | 61.12% |
| Justin "Sour J" Blair | 60.28% |
| Dominic "D-Stroyah" Nardini | 59.81% |
| Scotty “Too Hotty” Wilson | 59.56% |
| Dave "Boss Man" Schaller | 59.28% |
| John "Mr. Atomic" Shanahan | 58.68% |
| Dave "The DeRegulator" Barnes | 57.95% |
| Holly “Weed” Danowski | 57.91% |
| Eric ”Big Mo” Moberg | 57.82% |
| Andy “Obi-Wan” Obelnicki | 57.39% |
| James Creelman | 56.53% |
| Jared "Benoit Balls" Ose | 56.14% |
| Brad "Ford" Dupont | 55.77% |
| Michael “Fire” House | 55.67% |
| Emily “Slayer” May | 54.67% |
| Rick “Roll” Sinkiewicz | 54.64% |
| Ashton “Slim Shady” Capone | 54.61% |
| Andy “The Walrus” Stevens | 54.06% |
| Kevin "Bone Storm" Shea | 54.07% |
| Matthew "The Polish Hammer" Szewczyk | 53.78% |
| Lorenzo “The Big Ragu” Manginelli | 53.72% |
| Frank “The Flying Scotsman” Wallace | 53.52% |
| Jeffrey "Natural 20" Bondorew | 53.40% |
| Tom “Sweetheart” Coltart | 53.27% |
| Chris “Thunderdome” Dirga | 52.69% |
| Jim "Rowdy Roddy Piper 2" Campbell | 52.34% |
| Rick "The" Rock | 52.16% |
| Ted “T-Bone” Trautman | 51.79% |
| Keith ”The stump” Merril | 51.76% |
| John “The Nordique” Esposito | 51.13% |
| Bruce “Ready, Willing and” Kabel | 50.80% |
| Vin “The Chin” Tanuis | 50.30% |
| David “The Taxman” Tkacs | 49.77% |
| Patrick “Father John” Fenton Jr. | 49.41% |
| Eric "The Maker" Meyer | 49.33% |
| Ron “Canadian Thunder” Benoit | 49.23% |
| Wayne “Sweet Daddy” Savage | 49.20% |
| Adam "The Wrecker" Lopiano | 49.04% |
| Tom “The Machine” Nelson | 48.76% |
| Bill “Earthshaker” Galligan | 48.73% |
| Chris "Happy Feet" Harvey | 48.31% |
| Jim “The Irish Whisperer” O'Brien | 45.85% |
| Dylan "The Iron" Sheak | 43.87% |
| Bob “The Viper” Kane | 43.83% |
| Dan “The Razor” Carnein | 43.30% |
| Rob “Squints” Ferullo | 42.95% |
| Mike "Mike" Alves | 42.91% |
| Rick “The Quick” Eriksen | 42.84% |
| Joe “Git ‘er done” Duer | 42.68% |
| Kate "The Ace" Finegan | 41.84% |
| Lorrie "The Maverick" Schaller | 41.82% |
| Sam "Scream Bloody Gore" Stevens | 41.70% |
| Joshua "The Giggler" Martins | 41.32% |
| Ron “Slippery Pete” Houde | 40.30% |
| Steve “The Greaser” Longchamps | 39.99% |
| Nancy “The Punisher” Lennert | 39.86% |
| Peregrine “The Savage” Lennert | 39.65% |
| Jack "The Patched Pulverizer" Shanahan | 39.15% |
| Troy “The Mole” Damiano | 39.05% |
| Jim “Fire and Brimstone” Poliner | 38.82% |
| Eric “The Hammer” Szarejko | 38.74% |
| Ed "The Eraticator" Goll | 38.31% |
| Eric "Legs" Connoly | 37.96% |
| Dan “Candy” Kane | 36.05% |
| Gary "Gare-Bear The Knucklehead" Chobanian | 35.89% |
| Mike "Quick Draw" Lerch | 35.82% |
| Stephanie "The Horror" Harvey | 32.41% |
| Craig "The Pinsassin" DeMaria | 30.55% |
| Bill “The Scribe” Scheibel | 29.63% |
| Ellie "Hellfire" Pelletier | 29.22% |
| Dean “The Woodsman” Lennert | 24.64% |
| Alan “The Jammer” Jamiakowski | 24.54% |
| Chris “Smooth Talker” Scheibel | 23.74% |