| Matt "Dirty Optoz" Petrarca | 85.17% |
| Ed "Superfly" Giardina | 77.92% |
| Mike “I’m the Shit” Schmitt | 75.53% |
| Carl "Jailbones" Dupree | 67.62% |
| Scott "Flippy D" D'Agostino | 65.87% |
| Jared "Benoit Balls" Ose | 65.67% |
| Aaron "Sharing is Caring" Ciardullo | 55.75% |
| Matt "The Agent" Smith | 53.70% |
| Dave “Kosher Rabbi” Rabinowitz | 53.44% |
| Sheri "The Ringer" Hendricks | 51.66% |
| Justin "Jitterbug" Fontaine | 47.80% |
| Rebecca "Hot Stuff" Hopkins | 47.02% |
| Nick "The Quick" Galbiso | 40.62% |
| Mike "The. Mask" Masci | 39.05% |
| Denise "The Tiltress" Gautreau | 37.98% |
| Andrew "Federal" Hill | 37.60% |
| Mike "Revenge" Renzi | 34.81% |
| Shawne "The Shiv" Causgrove | 32.64% |
| Amber "The General" Lee | 30.90% |
| Colleen "Rowdy" Riley | 30.63% |
| Max "Air" Giardina | 26.34% |
| Michelle "Bamm Bamm" Barney | 25.53% |